Monday morning, at 9 a.m., the NCAA bell will toll for Penn State football. And of course, you know one thing is a lock: The Ohio Bobcats will still run out of that Beaver Stadium tunnel on September 1st.
"Unprecedented" sanctions, say the reports?
Oooohhhh. Can't wait, as Bart Scott would say.
Matt Hayes of the Sporting News, absolutely NAILS the way I feel about the NCAA and how they do business these days.
Excuse me if I can't get excited about an organization that saw Ohio State players accept cash in envelopes after coach Jim Tressel's lies and illegal benefits for players were exposed, but said lack of institutional control wasn't an issue.
If I can't get excited about an organization that knew Cecil Newton was shopping his son, Cam, to Mississippi State — yet let him continue to play at Auburn (and eventually win a national championship) — because it had no rule prohibiting parents from shopping their offspring to the highest bidder.
If I can't get excited about an organization that knows street agent Willie Lyles was paid $25,000 by Oregon for useless recruiting information; that knows Lyles was the "mentor" for five-star recruit Lache Seastrunk; that knows Oregon coach Chip Kelly lied when asked by a newspaper if he knew Lyles (Kelly later said, we call him 'Will'); that knows Kelly told Lyles he needed more recruiting information from Lyles after the fact, yet we're more than a year into the Oregon investigation with no end in sight.
If I can't get excited about an organization that looked at quite possibly the worst case of NCAA infractions in the history of the sport at North Carolina — in its depth and breadth of clear, indisputable illegal benefits and academic fraud issues — and decided it wasn't as destructive as a Southern Cal assistant coach who the NCAA claimed "knew or should have known" Reggie Bush was getting illegal benefits.
What happened at Penn State is the single greatest tragedy in sports history. Whatever penalties the university receives from the NCAA — whether or not the sport's governing body and Penn State agreed on them — isn't the point. If it were up to me, I'd shut down the program for the exact number of years the university hid the child abuse.
But this isn't about the penalties; it's about NCAA process.
You should read the whole piece by Hayes, because he acutely points out how this "wing it" approach by Emmert and the NCAA is going to come back and bite them on the ass, big time.
And guess what?
Penn State will likely be back after these sanctions, before you realize it. At which time, the conclusion will be obvious: the crime was worth the punishment. Just ask any other big time college football program.
With the conventional wisdom pointing towards the NCAA banning Penn State football from participating in any bowl games for a few years and the loss of scholarships I have to wonder what WOULD cause a team to warrant receiving the death penalty. Players robbing fans at gunpoint during halftime? Team-sponsored orgies with underage girls? A meth lab in the training room?ReplyDelete
I'm with you Czabe, shut 'em down!! Refresh my memory - What did SMU do to warrant the "death penalty"? Couldn't have been as bad as Penn State.ReplyDelete
One would hope for just punishment and I do believe that should be the death penalty for that program forever, but this is the NCAA. I have no faith in the NCAA whatsoever....ReplyDelete
The deal with 'The Death Penalty' is that it was created as a punishment for a team that gets busted deliberately breaking the rules while CURRENTLY already on probation.ReplyDelete
SMU kept getting busted, yet kept breaking the rules and everyone knew it. There was no real deterrent at the time for teams that were already on probation to make sure that they would be on their best behavior.
Reducing scholarships and allowing immediate transfer may actually be worse than the death penalty since it is going to decimate the football team from the inside out. The timing could be an issue this year for all but a few players, but it you will see a big change in the 2013 team. While there might be a small drop in attendance, they will still play games at Happy Valley the next 4 years. As much as the penalties seem like a cop out on the part of the NCAA, I think that Mark Emmert's comment that suspension of play would have a negative collateral impact on groups having nothing to do with this.ReplyDelete
Now that the punishment is out, it's ridiculous. Why vacate past wins? Not to condone PSU's behavior, of course, but their actions had nothing whatsoever to do with on-the-field performance. It's not like the players took steroids or otherwise cheated in a way that affected results.ReplyDelete
Should have Shut the Sonovabitch Down for at least ONE YEAR. If this situation doesn't warrant the Death Penalty, what does?ReplyDelete